86 Comments

This is an extraordinary sentence.

"James “Fergie” Chambers, the anarchist heir to a billionaire media fortune, recently promised $600,000 for the anti-training center campaign."

"Anarchist heir to a billionaire media fortune?"

I'm half expecting Tolstoy's ghost to whip his ass.

Expand full comment

Jezus...it’s the billionaires that funding cop city.....Fang knows that...why he’s pretending otherwise does not speak well for his honesty

https://news.littlesis.org/2022/11/15/meet-the-major-corporations-and-cultural-institutions-helping-build-cop-city-in-atlanta/

Expand full comment

That's irrelevant to my point: which is the so called "anarchists" protesting cop city are anything but.

They are shameful morons.

Expand full comment

Close to half of all Atlantans including a plurality of black residents oppose the center...despite the massively corporate funded campaign for it

It’s dishonest in the extreme to characterize the opposition as somehow a seditious plot of anarchist agitators

https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/23712765-buckhead_survey_public-1

Expand full comment

Hey jackass, are you actually looking to engage with me or just grind your talking points?

Because if it's the latter, you can fuck off.

Expand full comment

I just showed you a poll demonstrating the absolute ridiculousness of your contention that the opposition is some bunch of anarchists

Sorry that reality is so offensive to you

Expand full comment

They're not anarchists, just morons?

I'm relieved to hear that.

Expand full comment

That's not what the survey indicates. It indicates that the surveyed population is almost evenly divided, with a slightly greater number supporting the facility, and a somewhat higher numer of black residents opposing it.

Expand full comment

Well, that only makes sense. It's hard to have a business or culture in a crime ridden town.

So where are you from, Mr. Brown? Does this actually affect you or are you one of that 98 percent who doesn't live there and would rather see Atlanta burn than give up your "pastime" of "saving" the unwashed masses from themselves?

Expand full comment

I’m not giving my exact address on the internet. But, yes, I live really, really close and--like myself--all my neighbors oppose the urban warfare center

And the corporations funding this center don’t operate local businesses. My neighbors who do...aren’t in favor of paying to have our green space destroyed in favor of a urban warfare crowd control training center

Expand full comment

And the article you cited lists Waffle House, Home Depot, Chick-fil-A, etc. Last I checked, those all had local outlets.

Expand full comment

Again..as clearly you’re not local...those “local” outlets do everything they can to avoid paying taxes and reinvesting in the community, their executives don’t send their kids to public schools and--in fact--most of them live in the affluent exurbs like Alpharetta or John’s Creek. They have no stake in the safety of my community...and they don’t care

Expand full comment

The people who work for them live in your community. The people who buy from them live in your community. It seems you've conveniently forgotten that.

Expand full comment

Sure, sure. It seems you might have mentioned that to Phisto Sobannii rather than citing a very small survey. How many people does Atlanta have? And they asked 800 people. And from that you make such grand statements.

Expand full comment

That “small survey” was conducted by a local university....which has some national renown and reputation

As you clearly know nothing about Atlanta...I won’t hold that against you

Expand full comment

Emory might be a "renowned" university, but they are enthrall to a certain group of people who think being awake is "helping" us plebes by getting rid of police and leaving us to the mercy of the worse elements of society. And it's still an incredibly small survey. 800 people is basically .2 percent of the population.

Finally, remember, a police force is often a direct reflection of the population it serves and vice versa.

Expand full comment

On the internet, no one knows you're a dog.

Expand full comment

He is a member of the Cox family, who own the Atlanta Journal Constitution and the WSB Radio and Television brand. WSB stands for “Welcome South, Brother.” Anarchists are no brother of mine or anyone here in Metro Atlanta. I am infuriated that Judge Robert McBurney extended the deadline to collect signatures for the petition.

Expand full comment

I’d gently suggest Mr. Chambers and his ilk do not represent even the worst, much less the best, of the historical anarchist tradition.

Expand full comment

Who is ultimately funding these types of movements? The international presence, as well as the high production values and swift reaction times, suggest something other than organic movements.

Expand full comment

Maybe I’ll write about that

Expand full comment

Absolutely do that.

It does seem that many of those funding these movements to eliminate police are fine with investing in private “security” for themselves.

Expand full comment

Please do - we need to drag them into the light and expose them, so that we’ll-meaning but misguided folks can see what they’re supporting, for one.

Expand full comment

How about you do a better job of investigating Manuel Teran's death instead of just reciting police narratives? You could write a story about that. You seem to be an environmentalist on some issues Lee, but your callous disregard for the death of this environmental protestor at the hands police shocks me.

"According to the autopsy sent to ABC News, Teran did not have gunpowder residue on their hands."

https://abcnews.go.com/US/dekalb-county-releases-autopsy-cop-city-protester-manuel/story?id=98700731

Expand full comment

How much corporate donations has the pro urban warfare center side received?

I challenge you to honesty answer that question

Expand full comment

As a person who lives very close by, I assure you that the opposition is organic.

It’s the other side that has received millions in corporate donations

Expand full comment

Why aren’t there class action lawsuits against the people/organizations who fund violent protestors? They are basically representatives of these organizations and the organizations should be held responsible.

Expand full comment

These “protesters” really don’t seem to understand that they, themselves, are the Fascists. I’m so sick of stupid humans.

Expand full comment

Many years ago, as a journalist, I covered the city of East St. Louis across the Mississippi River from St. Louis. And East St. Louis was almost all-black and poor, once described as "an inner city without an outer city." Crime was rampant but when I walked the neighborhoods and talked with residents, almost without exception they always told me "We need more police." (And better schools, and jobs, as well.)

Things haven't changed much. But now, as Lee documents so well, we have an odious group of leftists making things worse -- for the very people they claim to care for!

These misguided, angry, rebellious men (mostly) -- well, I actually think that deep down, they feel helpless, they've heard too much demonizing of the police, they have lost faith in the rule of law, and they think they can redeem themselves by becoming street warriors. I pity them but also oppose them, certainly their tactics.

But where are the Democratic party leaders -- local and national -- who can show up at protests to counsel and lead these radicals to a better, more effective way of social change? We also have a crisis of leadership if the Democratic Party leaders stay silent.

Expand full comment

I believe the Democratic party leadership is much too busy censoring social media and attempting to start WWIII.

Expand full comment

Just read this over on Public, about progressive fact checkers.

“A group of Swiss psychologists actually examined the relationship between leftist authoritarianism and narcissistic behavior. They concluded that “some leftist political activists do not actually strive for social justice and equality but rather use political activism to endorse or exercise violence against others to satisfy their own ego-focused needs.”

Sounds like every antifa fascist on earth.

Expand full comment

With the heavy funding from special interests and huge corporations pouring in on both sides (Cop City reportedly has its own corporate and private equity investors including Roark Capital and Inspire Brands), I have lots of questions. The fact that Meta and some billionaire's "anarchist" kid are financing a protest movement, one where young environmentalists are being killed, is so bizarre to me. (Imagine the anti-war protests of the 1960s being funded by a TV station -- totally normal, right?)

Like others, I do feel the activists deserved a voice in this though, especially given all the talk about potential training for urban warfare against citizens at this facility (I'm not sure if those rumors have been verified yet).

I would love to see a follow up piece looking at the funding sources across the board, and hearing what the protestors have to say (and what they're being told), and how that might differ from what city officials are saying/being told, and what local citizens are saying/being told. It just feels like maybe there's a lot more going on here.

Expand full comment

Thanks EMM for voicing closest to my own questions after the Lee Fang interview I saw that seemed uncharacteristically one sided for power.

Red flags for me were the private funding, public objection/community voice, historical references (correctional center, indigenous origins), environmental impact, community impact, absence of alternatives in location or scale. And what about the decision timing, any possible White House influence? Setting purpose aside, what seems this controversial monstrosity isn't even in Atlanta. Looks like plenty to expand and clarify.

https://edition.cnn.com/2022/09/24/us/atlanta-public-safety-training-center-plans-community/index.html

Expand full comment

Def! Lee Fang is an awesome journalist, so I feel like he might write more about this. This is just one story. I'm assuming he'll cover other angles of it (he actually mentioned doing this in the comments), so I just wanted to add my thoughts as a reader.

Expand full comment

Thank you Lee. I heard u discussing this subject with Glenn Greenwald on SYSTEM UPDATE. Very enlightening, as well as unfortunate/tragic, sowing anarchy. (Violence for Violence’s sake! How counterproductive! Falling right into the “Security State’s” hands! Uughh!

Expand full comment

“But no attempted engagement has pacified the movement.”

Really? An anarchist movement hasn’t been pacified by “engagement”? Wow!

wow

Expand full comment

The comments here show why only paid subscribers are allowed on most Substacks.

Expand full comment

In case anyone is wondering, I found what appears to be the ICAT lesson plans.

https://www.policeforum.org/assets/ICAT/ICAT_Module1_Aug2021.pdf

Found the below on page 2. Does this sound like something you'd find in an "urban warfare center?"

"Lessons from Abroad

o In 2015, PERF Executive Director Chuck Wexler was in

Scotland with several American police chiefs for a

leadership development program, and decided to attend a

recruit graduation. Knowing that only about 2 percent of

police officers in Scotland carry firearms, Wexler asked a

Scottish officer, “How do you deal with people brandishing

knives, when you don’t have a firearm?”

o The Scottish officer said, “It’s no problem. We stand back,

we assess the situation.” He proceeded to describe Police

Scotland’s approach to critical thinking, de-escalation, and

tactics for resolving these incidents.

o The American police chiefs were shocked when Scottish

police officials explained that they receive 1.8 million

emergency calls per year, including thousands of incidents

involving persons with knives, but most years go by without

the police in Scotland shooting a single person.

o So in November 2015, at PERF’s request, Police Scotland

hosted a delegation of police chiefs and other high-ranking

officials from nearly 25 American police agencies, for four

days of training demonstrations, presentations, and candid

discussions about Scotland’s strategies for resolving

incidents. "

Expand full comment

America is unraveling.

We no longer have free speech, ie feel free to speak.

We are divided not united.

Law and order is being challenged.

Our right to bear arms, ie protect ourselves is threatened.

Our economy and currency is weakened.

Seems we need to reconsider what we value and strongly defend those things. They aren’t guaranteed.

Expand full comment

Herbert Marcuse is probably grinning in his grave, and trying like hell to raise his fist. 🤦‍♂️

Expand full comment

Interesting for me that these Atlanta activists, the BLM Global Network and Just Stop Oil are all receiving funds from billionaires and multi millionaires.

Why?

Expand full comment

This story & the comments that follow it is a perfect example of the dismaying information/disinformation jumble that we face today. What, in all of the “evidence” cited above is reliable? Are any salient facts or arguments missing? Can anyone be trusted? Too bad for me, I’m an adult & will have to figure it out for myself.

Expand full comment

We live in a ridiculous police state. The 1% are the biggest criminals!

Expand full comment

anybody that funds this while pays for private security needs to be publicly shamed. This demand of defunding the police serves the need of a few at the cost of many.

Expand full comment

I agree but, realistically, what can you expect? A society without police will devolve to mob rule, with the most violent and aggressive individuals calling the shots. The billionaires who seek to deliver that dystopia may be evil but they aren’t knuckleheads. Put yourself in their Les Ruby Slippers: wouldn’t you be more than a little concerned about the mob coming for you? Most of them wouldn’t be taking kindly to your plundering of resources and your self-aggrandizing exploitation of your social lessers. You would probably want a Sherman tank in your garage.

Expand full comment